Pricing High to Leave Room? Why It Can Cost You When Selling in Greater Victoria
The Daniel Collective
“Let’s start a little higher. We can always come down.”
It sounds reasonable. You want the best price for your home, and you expect buyers to negotiate. Why not give yourself some room?
Because buyers have to see value before they decide to negotiate.
If you’re selling a home in Greater Victoria, an inflated asking price can work against both your timeline and your final result.
Buyers may move on before making an offer
Your home is competing with everything else a buyer can purchase at that price. If the alternatives offer more, buyers may simply book those showings instead.
Price also determines which searches your home appears in. A buyer with a $1.2 million ceiling may never see your $1.275 million listing, even if you would happily negotiate into their range.
You may have left room for a conversation that never happens.
What do local sale prices tell us?
The Victoria Real Estate Board’s September 2026 statistics reported these rounded figures:
Property category - Single-family residential*
Sale to List Price Ratio - 98% (last listed price)
Days on Market - 43 (last listed price)
Property category - Condo apartments*
Sale to List Price Ratio - 97% (last listed price)
Days on Market - 56 (last listed price)
Single-family category excludes separately reported waterfront and acreage properties. Figures cover the VREB region rather than individual neighbourhoods.
At 98%, a $1 million asking price translates to a $980,000 sale. But that doesn’t mean you can inflate your asking price and expect buyers to pay 98% of it.
These figures describe homes that actually sold. They do not show that overpricing works or provide a comparison of original asking prices across first, second and third listing attempts.
“Sold close to asking” tells only part of the story
Consider this hypothetical example:
A home starts at $1.2 million, drops to $1.1 million, then sells for $1.078 million.
That is 98% of the revised asking price, but only 89.8% of the original asking price.
Does that mean the seller lost $122,000 in market value? No. The original price may never have been achievable.
It does show why the final sale price and the full listing history matter more than a percentage on its own.
Chasing the market can get expensive
While a home sits, mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, utilities and maintenance continue. Buyers may also begin wondering why it hasn’t sold and whether the seller will accept a larger discount.
If competing homes become cheaper while you make small reductions, you can remain overpriced at every step.
That is chasing the market: adjusting to yesterday’s conditions while buyers shop today’s options.
A lower eventual selling price, combined with months of carrying costs, can leave you with less money than a realistic launch might have produced. It’s a risk, not an inevitable outcome.
Start with the evidence
A Broadmead family home, a Gordon Head property and an Oak Bay character house need different comparable sales. The same applies across Sidney, Esquimalt, View Royal, Langford and Colwood.
At The Daniel Collective, our approach starts with recent sales, current competition and an honest conversation about your timeline. Then we watch showing activity, buyer feedback and competing sales, and respond when the evidence calls for it.
Your asking price should give buyers a reason to take your home seriously.
Thinking about selling your home in Greater Victoria? Contact The Daniel Collective at hello@tdcrealestate.ca to arrange a no-obligation meeting. We’ll discuss your home’s current market value and build a pricing strategy around what buyers are paying, your timeline and your goals.